Mold erosion

In the field of foundry technology, the term mold erosion (from the Latin erodere, meaning “to eat away”) refers to the erosive (abrasive) wear of permanent metal molds.

Erosive mold wear means the continued material loss at the mold surface due to the contact and relative movement between the mold surface and the incoming melt.

In addition to thermal damage to the mold, local surface abrasion of the die casting molds also plays an important role for the service life. The highest stresses mainly occur in the vicinity of the gate at the contour areas which are in direct contact with the flowing melt, resulting in increasing surface roughness.

These tribological stresses on the mold are even further intensified by the abrasive effect of the silicon contained in almost all aluminum alloys and of oxides and intermetallic phases. The resulting damage to the mold surface is called erosion. The rough surfaces caused by this erosion exhibit an increased propensity to soldering.

Erosive mold wear is believed to be primarily influenced by the following aspects:

 

  • Geometry (in particular of the gate, narrow radii, sharp edges, etc.)
  • Velocity and angle of impact of the melt onto the mold during the mold filling process (see Flow rate in pressure die casting, Flow rate in the gate)
  • Time of the exposure to wear stresses
  • Maximum temperature and time- and site-related temperature pattern or gradient and temperature changes

In addition to the mold filling quality, the gate is critical for erosion in die casting molds. Here, weld spots at the walls of the mold cavity should also be prevented. Sharp edges, as they appear on core and ejector pins, for example, are inevitable and are particularly prone to wear. Turbulences and cavitation also promotes wear and should therefore be avoided.

Adhesion, soldering, corrosion and warm cracks increase with a rising mold temperature, while the erosion temperature decreases with a falling mold temperature. Concerning adhesion, the chemical reaction rate rising together with the temperature is essential. Erosion, on the other hand, rather depends on viscosity or the fraction of the melt which has already changed to the pasty state.

The following describes the theories on abrasive erosion for the pressure die casting of aluminum alloys according to Z. W. Chen and M. Z. Jahedi:

Impact erosion by a drop of liquid

The most important theory for understanding impact erosion caused by liquid metal drops is that of guided acoustic shock (GAS). This theory explains the impact of a high-velocity liquid drop on a plane surface based on two effects (see Fig. 1):

1. Direct influence of the impact pressure on the mold surface, and
2. subsequent near-surface washout in transverse direction (lateral liquid jet)

The mean impact pressure of an accelerated liquid drop is as follows according to eq. 1:

Eq.1: p_{imp} = 
</p><p>ho _l cdot c_s cdot v_{imp}

pimpMean impact pressure
ρlMetal density in the liquid state
csAcoustic velocity of the melt
vimpImpact velocity of the liquid drop

Pursuant to Fig. 1b, the highest impact pressure occurs at the circumference of the shock front and can be up to twice as high as the mean impact pressure pimp , i.e. according to eq. 2:

Eq. 2:p_{max} approx 2 cdot p_{imp}

Studies for determining acoustic velocity in liquid molten metal show values of about 1,000-2,800 m/s. Assuming a gate speed of 50 m/s typical for aluminum die casting and an acoustic velocity in liquid aluminum of 2,500 m/s as per W. Schaafs, this yields the following mean impact pressure according to eq. 3:

Eq. 3:p_{imp} = 
</p><p>ho _l cdot c_s = 2700 frac{kg}{m^3} cdot 2500 frac{m}{s} cdot 50 frac{m}{s} = 338 M!Pa

and the following maximum impact pressure based on eq. 4:

Eq. 4:p_{max} approx 2 cdot p_{imp} approx 676 M!Pa

The resistance of the die casting mold to the impact pressure depends on the strength of the hot-forming steel. At an assumed melt temperature of 570°C to 600°C, the hot-forming steel 1.2343 has a strength of approx 600–820 MPa depending on its hardness (Fig. 2). Especially in areas of low mold hardness and high gate speeds, the stresses caused by the impact pressures can be greater than the yield strength of 1.2343. However, it can generally be assumed that damage due to impact erosion is low compared to other damage mechanisms such as soldering, even though it is not negligible even at high casting temperatures and very high gate speeds. Therefore, at a high melt temperature and speeds of > 60 m/s, significant damage due to impact erosion must be expected after several thousand cycles and a long incubation time.

Particle erosion

In recent years, studies (in particular those of Venkatesan and Shivpuri) have shown that the main cause for erosion can be induced by solid particles in the melt. This particularly refers to pre-solidified silicon particles forming in the goose neck, but also to oxides and intermetallic phases which result in increased abrasive wear of the mold surface. In order to assess the erosive effect of particles, it is reasonable to compare the hardness of the die casting mold and the particle hardness. At realistic melt temperatures of 570 to 650°C (depending on superheat and retention time of the melt in the goose neck), pre-solidified silicon particles have the following hardness values:

Hardness of primary Si particles at 570°C: ~ 30 HRC and 650°C: ~ 20 HRC

As can also be seen in Fig. 3, the hardness of a hot-forming steel held at a high temperature for 100h is close to the hardness range of the pre-solidified silicon particles, however, this does not mean that the erosion can be completely attributed to the influence of Si particles. The extent to which pre-solidified primary aluminum solid solutions support this type of erosion as soft particles of the same species has not yet been adequately explained and is doubtful, especially since the hardness of the α-Al particles is approx. 10 times lower (~20 HV) than that of hot-forming steel (> 30 HV, ~ 30 HRC). However, the long-term effect of hard particles has also not been completely clarified yet.

Cavitation erosion

Cavitation is a result of the formation and subsequent collapse of blisters in the mold due to local differences in pressure. Both Preece and Hansson state in their studies that cavitation and gas blisters can occur when the vapor pressure of the melt is exceeded in areas of intense baffles or in the flow shadow behind cores and edges. The die casting professional knows cavitation defects in the area of these sites inside the cavity, even though there are no confirmed studies up to now.

It can be concluded that all 3 erosion mechanisms – impact erosion, particle erosion and cavitation erosion – damage the die casting mold in the course of its lifetime, the predominant mechanism depending on the given geometry, velocities, alloy and time. Examples of erosion defects on die casting molds are shown in Figs. 4 and 5.

Literature references:
Chen Z. W., Jahedi M. Z., Die erosion and its effect on soldering formation in high pressure die casting of aluminium alloys, Materials and design 20 (1999), p. 303-309.
Preece C. M., Erosion treaties of materials science and technology, Preece C. M., New York Academic Press, 1979, p. 249-308.
Hansson C. M., ASM Handbook, Vol. 19, 1992, ASM International, p. 214-220.
Venkatesan K., Shivpuri R.: An investigation of the effect of process parameters on the washout in die casting dies, 18th international Die Casting Congress and Exposition, Indianapolis, USA (1995), p. 361-371.

Additional references:
Chipping
Erosion
Firing cracks
Stress cracks

  • Fig. 1: Impact of a melt drop on the mold, impact pressures and formation of a liquid jet
  • Fig. 2:  Yield strength of 1.2343 as a function of hardness and temperature, and impact pressure as a function of gate speed
  • Fig. 3: Comparison of the hardness of pre-solidified Si particles and the hardness of the hot-forming steel 1.2343 upon holding temperature for 100h
  • Fig. 4: Mold erosion in the gating area of a die casting mold, source: FT&amp;E Foundry Technologies &amp; Engineering GmbH
  • Fig. 5:  Mold erosion defect in the area of flow washouts (probable mainly cavitation erosion), source: FT&amp;E Foundry Technologies &amp; Engineering GmbH
Back to list